Tim Ashley 

Saint-Saëns: Symphonies 1 and 2, Phaéton CD review – carefully considered

Conductor Marc Soustrot and the Malmö Symphony give strong symphonic performances, but could do with more bite
  
  

Conductor Marc Soustrot
Strong performance … Marc Soustrot Photograph: /.

Saint-Saëns wrote five symphonies, of which only the Third, the “organ Symphony”, has remained in regular repertoires. Marking the start of a new complete cycle, this thoughtful disc allows us to assess its predecessors. Saint-Saëns, a teen prodigy, wrote his First Symphony aged 17, though it was not accepted for performance until he passed the manuscript off as a work by an anonymous German composer.If you didn’t know who wrote it, you would probably think it was by Schumann.

The Second, however, dating from 1859, is a taut, lean piece that flies in the face of both the Romantic and symphonic traditions by opening with an astringent fugue, and contains a compact, remarkably beautiful adagio. Phaéton (1873), which depicts the disastrous attempt by Apollo’s son to drive his father’s chariot through the heavens, is among the most original and striking of Saint-Saëns’s symphonic poems.

The performances from Marc Soustrot and the Malmö Symphony are strong and carefully considered, which admirably suits the symphonies, though Phaéton could do with more energy and bite.

 

Leave a Comment

Required fields are marked *

*

*