Northern Sinfonia/Zehetmair

Sage, GatesheadThomas Zehetmair never conducts more effectively than with a violin tucked under his chin, writes Alfred Hickling

Hallé/Elder

Bridgewater Hall, ManchesterMark Elder unleashed Mahler's revered Ninth with as much force as he could without the audience suing for assault, and ended it with a whisper, writes Alfred Hickling

RLPO/Vasily Petrenko

Philharmonic Hall, Liverpool Unusually for Vasily Petrenko, this version of Mahler's Third Symphony felt like an unfinished interpretation, writes Tim Ashley

Hallé/BBCPO/Elder

Bridgewater Hall, ManchesterThe Mahler in Manchester series tackled the cultish vastness of the Eighth with operatic urgency, writes Tim Ashley

BBC Philharmonic/Noseda

Bridgewater Hall, ManchesterGianandrea Noseda's high-octane performance of Mahler's least neurotic symphony was marvellous, writes Tim Ashley

BBC Philharmonic/Noseda

Bridgewater Hall, ManchesterErotic cool and exacting ferocity defined the latest concert in the Mahler in Manchester series, writes Tim Ashley

RSNO/Denève

This programme saw a performance of Mahler's Sixth from Stéphane Denève and the RSNO that rather lacked the requisite menace, writes Rowena Smith

BRSO/Jansons

Mariss Jansons was hypnotic with both Mahler and Shostakovich, writes Martin Kettle – but was it really worth his orchestra's trip from Munich?

Hallé/Elder

Bridgewater Hall, ManchesterCapitalising from the relatively concise span of Mahler's Fifth, the Hallé under Mark Elder were on fire, writes Alfred Hickling

Hallé/Stenz

Bridgewater Hall, ManchesterThe Manchester Mahler retrospective took a tempestuous turn with this radical take on the Fourth, writes Tim Ashley